Back To Previous

Finger Lakes

Fly-By-Night Cookie Company

14508 Fancher Avenue, Fair Haven, NY 13064

Phone: (315) 947-5588

Offering an amazing variety of scratch made cookies. Fresh fruit and cream pies, scones, danish, cream puffs, savory pocket pies, specialty whole grain breads. Also offering party platters and a cookie mailing service. Gift assortments and cookie cards. For children and miniature enthusiasts check out the ever growing 'Hamlet of Minimally.' Stop by and step into Baba Yaga's Tea Room and enjoy a beverage and the specialty pastry of the day! Tucked away in the back is the West Barrier Bar BOOKNOOK. The BOOKNOOK is filled with hundreds of gently used books of every sort.